Review of Uncanny X-Men Issue #16

photo 2-3

Uncanny X-Men Issue #16 (January 10, 1966)

Story By: Stan Lee         Art By: Jack Kirby and Werner Roth

Rating: 2.5 out of 5 stars

Brief Description: Have the Sentinels triumphed over the X-Men, or will they be struck down from within their own ranks? Before it’s over, someone will die!

Characters Introduced in This Issue: None

Recurring Characters in This Issue: Master Mold, Bolivar Trask, Sentinels, Professor X, Iceman, Beast, Angel, Jean Grey, Cyclops

Synopsis:

This issue concludes the first sentinel saga. As the issue begins, the X-Men are being held captive in a heavy gravity chamber while Professor X is stranded outside of the sentinels’ base.

As the X-Men try to escape from their prison, Professor X uses his telepathic power to get himself a ride back to the television station where he debated Bolivar Trask. In the station there is still a sentinel that is out of commission on the floor and Professor X investigates why it stopped working.

The Professor realizes that there is a strange crystal in a tower nearby that shut down the sentinel. With the help of the army, Professor X is able to bring the giant crystal to the sentinel base and shut down many of the sentinels.

Screen shot 2014-05-20 at 2.32.52 PM

This happens at the perfect time because this is exactly when the X-Men are able to escape their prison.

While the X-Men briefly battle the sentinels, Master Mold is ordering Trask to make him an army of sentinels. Fearing the fate of humanity, Trask blows up the base, killing himself and all of the remaining sentinels, including the Master Mold. The X-Men are able to escape the explosion unharmed.

photo 4

Review:

This issue is a bit of a step up from the last issue, but I do not think that it is a very good ending to the first sentinel saga. The defeat of Master Mold and the sentinels seemed way too easy and the X-Men didn’t really do anything.

I really did not like the special “crystal” that stopped the sentinels. Where did that crystal come from? Why did it stop the sentinels? It seemed like too much of an easy way out for Professor X.

Once the crystal did its work on the sentinels, Bolivar Trask saved the day by blowing up the base. I liked this for some reasons, but I also disliked this. It was great to see Trask showing remorse and taking responsibility for his actions. It was also great to see the first definitive (maybe) death of the series. I wished to see Trask for longer, but this was a fitting end for him. What I didn’t like about Trask blowing up the sentinels was that the X-Men didn’t help out at all. While Trask was blowing up the base, the X-Men were losing their battle with the sentinels.

photo 4-1

I think that Stan Lee could’ve found a way for the X-Men to do something in this finale issue. The comic is called X-Men, not Professor X and Bolivar Trask.

The sentinel saga started out promising, but I wanted a lot more out of the story than I got. I hope that the Days of Future Past movie does sentinels a better justice than this comic story arc.

A Few Final Notes:

1. I enjoyed the X-Men getting beat up panels.

photo 1-2 photo 1-1

2. Iceman is happy that Cyclops calls him a man for the first time, which doesn’t quite make sense because everyone calls him Iceman.

photo 5-1

3. I thoroughly enjoyed this personal note where Marvel instructs you how to make a “gravity globe”.

photo 2-2

4. Professor X continues to have connections to the government.

photo 5

5. After a few issues without any sexual tension, there is some more Jean Grey-Cyclops stuff.

photo 3

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Review of Uncanny X-Men Issue #16

  1. Looking forward to seeing your review of the Sentinels return, bigger and badder. Er… I guess I should have said Spoiler alert… (as if anyone doesn’t know that the Sentinels return…)

    • I can’t wait for them to return. I hope the next sentinel saga is a a bit better than this one. The first issue started off so well, but there were some flaws in the next 2 issues.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s