Review of Uncanny X-Men Issue #17

photo 2-3

Uncanny X-men Issue #17 (February 10, 1966)

Story By: Stan Lee        Art By: Jack Kirby and Werner Roth 

Rating: 2 out of 5 stars

Brief Description: The first Sentinel Saga is over, but metal can be dangerous even when it’s not in the form of robots! Just ask…Magneto!

Characters Introduced in This Issue: None

Recurring Characters in This Issue: Magneto, Professor X, Iceman, Beast, Angel, Jean Grey, Cyclops


This issue takes place directly after the events of issue 16. The X-Men are wounded after their battle with the sentinels and the army brings them to the hospital where they recuperate.

photo 1-2

While in the hospital, Professor X senses something strange at his mansion and sends Angel to investigate. Angel arrives, but is incapacitated by an unknown villain when he crashes into glass plating.

After losing mental contact with Angel, Professor X and Cyclops then return to the mansion and are also defeated by traps that were specifically made for them. Professor X gets his brain shut down by a machine and Cyclops gets trapped in a dark chamber full of glass walls. Cyclops tries to resist capture, but is knocked out by a punch from the mysterious villain.

photo 3-1

After not hearing from the Professor in a while, Jean Grey fears the worst and she and Beast go back to the mansion. Beast is defeated by running into a hallway that is full of completely frictionless surfaces. Beast cannot slow down or stop and he crashes into a trap door. Jean is knocked out by sleeping gas.

photo 5photo 4

While all of this is happening, Iceman is in a coma in the hospital.

As the issue ends, the villain sends the captured X-Men into space in a steel space craft with the intention that they will eventually run out of air and die. In the last panel, Angel’s parents come to the mansion to visit their son and Magneto answers the door, revealing that he is behind this plot.

photo 2


photo 1


In this issue I am happy to see the return of Magneto, but there is one big problem with this comic. Issue 17 feels more like a lead in issue than an issue that works on its own. It seems like the sole purpose of this issue is to build suspense for issue 18.

Not much actually happens in this issue. Half of the panels take place in a hospital and aren’t that exciting. I only needed one panel with Professor X trying to pretend that he doesn’t know the X-Men.

photo 4-1

The traps that Magneto sets for the X-Men are interesting, but the X-Men really don’t put up any fight. They seem helpless against Magneto. It also seems a bit strange that the X-Men would go to the mission in small groups instead of together. They use the injuries to try and explain why they did this, but besides Iceman they all seem to heal fast. They definitely could have all (except Iceman) went to the mansion together. If they did that, they may not have become trapped.

This issue successfully made me very excited for Iceman to face off against Magneto by himself in the next issue. This is the biggest cliffhanger that X-Men has had yet and it is an exciting one. However, I wanted more out of this issue. This was not a bad issue, but it was not the best I’ve read.

A few final notes:

1. They are really setting up Iceman to succeed. There were a few panels where Iceman mumbled in his coma that he needed to make his fellow X-Men proud. I assume Iceman will save the day in the next issue.

photo 5-1

2. Beast is the only one who still acts sexist towards Jean.

photo 1-1

3. Also Beast’s large vocabulary is starting to annoy his fellow X-Men.

photo 2-2

9 thoughts on “Review of Uncanny X-Men Issue #17

  1. The Burning Blogger Of Bedlam says:

    This is a great site, dude. I’m an Uncanny X-Men loyalist, but even I’m not fully versed in the entire canonical history. Good stuff 🙂

      • The Burning Blogger Of Bedlam says:

        Yeah, it’s all about those little details, origin stories, etc. Out of curiosity then, what to you is the best era of X-Men comics?

      • Hmm that’s a tough question and my answer may change after I read all of Uncanny X-Men but for now I’m gonna say the Chris Claremont era. He really added a lot more depth to the X-Men. When it comes to non “Uncanny X-Men” comics, I’m a big fan of what Joss Whedon did with Astonishing X-Men.

      • The Burning Blogger Of Bedlam says:

        Cool. I agree with Chris Claremont era too; though I haven’t read everything there is to read, so I too might have to change my opinion some day.

  2. I could never really buy into the idea that the original 5 would be able to stand up to the abilities of Magneto. He just seems to powerful compared to what the X-Men were capable of at the time (Jean could really only float toasters in the air at this point).

    Anyway, you’ve got a long road ahead of you Kevin – I feel like this is one of the last decent issues of X-Men until Neal Adams shows up (just in time for the title to be cancelled…).

    • Yeah it is true that without Professor X, Magneto could easily defeat the original 5 X-Men in the early stages of their powers.

      And I know it’s gonna take a very long time but it’ll be a fun journey! I’m a little worried about after Stan Lee leaves X-Men, but a bad X-Men comic is still better than a lot of other comics.

      And do you mean the years from 1970 until Chris Claremont took over that there was no X-Men??? Because I hope you don’t mean that the new run is being cancelled because that would be very sad.

      • Fewf yeah ok that was what the era I was thinking about. Haha I’m excited for that part because I will be able to go from reviewing issue #66 to jumping to issue #94 in one day instead of a whole month of reviews.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s